
Creative Team:
Sophie Campbell (WRITER, ARTIST, and COVER), Tamra Bonvillain (COLORS), and Becca Carey (LETTERS).
This is a joint review by Matt of Hops ‘Geek’ News and Megan of Vigilante Vibes Podcast!
SPOILERS AHEAD
The Story
Matt – Cyborg Supergirl was unexpected but also a nice change of pace! The science council thought they were doing the right thing, were truly in the wrong, and so seeing how they justified themselves against Kara, who remained aware of what was going on throughout the book, was a great back and forth dillema. Especially as the more we get from Black Flame, the more I find myself agreeing with them. Sophie does a great job blurring the lines of who is right and who is wrong, showing us that not everything is always black and white.
Megan – The battle between the Science Council and Black Flame intensifies to new heights! Supergirl is without her powers as she doesn’t have her Yellow Ring of Nor-Kann and is gravely injured. She’s taken to the Science Council who perform life-saving measurements to help Kara without her permission. Kara wakes up to brand new cyborg parts added to her body that can make her the ultimate weapon.
This issue was very eye-opening in showing how toxic the Science Council truly is, and Kara is more than aware. It seems that every step the council takes in order to stop Black Flame, Kara rightfully disagrees with. Although Black Flame is the villain, as she’s the rebel of Kandor, she’s starting to seem to have a point. The tone of the comic will have you second guessing who the actual villains are of the story, which I think is a testament to the writer’s fantastic writing talents. Sophie Campbell continues to knock Supergirl’s story out of the park with the depth she provides, and the emotions that ring loudly in the story.
The Art
Matt – Speaking of cyborg Supergirl, I loved the various little details Sophie put in, such as around her eyes or throughout various parts of her, which made Kara look wicked awesome. The color worked as the battle began to rage and we see more of Kandor stood out as there was a ton of vibrant colors being used to pop off the panels. The various characters were all given their own flair, making them stand out and making this one visually appealing.
Megan – Sophie Campbell, Tamra Bonvillain and Becca Carey bring a great amount of excitement to the pages of Supergirl #12. Besides Kara looking really cool with her cyborg gear, the other characters are drawn to shine on their own. Each character has their own vibe that Sophie Campbell captures well. Tamra Bonvillain handles the colors, giving the story a beautiful vibrancy with each page looking like a work of art with juxtaposing bright colors. Becca Carey is the letterer, and delivers top quality work as always. What I really appreciate about Carey is how she portrays the sound effects of the comic, making you feel each effect and getting a better vision of the story.
Final Thoughts
Matt – 8.5/10. While I did enjoy this issue, I do feel it was slightly jarring, but not in a bad way. I am excited to see where Sophie takes this story, as I have loved every issue and will keep this one at the top of my pull list!
Megan – 8.8/10. I’m very excited to see where this battle goes with Kara and Black Flame, and especially interested to see what happens with the Science Council.
Overall Grade -8.7/10
Let us know in the comments what you thought of Supergirl #12!























