“Witchblade: Samhain Special” Review – A Halloween Carol

Published:

The Run Down

Are you like me where you’ve always wondered why no one’s done a “Christmas Carol” type story for Halloween or Samhain? Well have no fear as that day is here! Writers Matt Hawkins, Ryan Cady, and Marc Silvestri crafted an amazing series of tales wrapped in a familiar bow. Here, we see Sara learn from three previous wielders of the witchblade on one fateful Samhain Eve in New York.

Writers: Matt Hawkins, Ryan Cady, Marc Silvestri
Artists: Pat Boutin, Laura Braga
Colorist: Gibran Ferdian
Letterer: Troy Peteri

Source: Pat Boutin, Arif Prianto, Image Comics

“Leonor and the Magdalena”

In this fantastic opening story from writers Matt Hawkins and Ryan Cady, Sara meets the ghost of Leonor Di Palma. Together, Hawkins and Cady introduce us to the genius wrap around that surrounds the entire issue. I’ll admit, I was quite surprised by the direction but I absolutely love it! The pace of this first issue was absolutely spectacular, not being too slow or too fast. If the title of the next issue is anything to go by, this could also be a bit of lead into the next overall arc for “Witchblade”. That being said, the particular backstory on display here was full of intense action and emotion that left my heart racing!

As for the art from Pat Boutin, what he put on display here was absolutely incredible! Despite all of the magic and things going on, Boutin managed to make things feel grounded in realism. The way that he’s able to include so much on a page without it feeling like too much is a feat unto itself. This is helped even more by the fantastic colors of Ferdian, who manages to ground everything with realistic lighting and colors that feel perfect for the setting.

“Esma and Gareth”

Now,I’ll say right off of the bat this is probably the slowest of the three stories. That being said, it’s no slouch either! While this story from Cady feels a bit predictable, that doesn’t make it any less exciting. In just a few short pages, he manages to show us a woman’s rise and fall at the mighty hand of trust. In that time, he shows off a whole relationship while making us feel the emotion. The fact that he’s able to do that is an incredible feat unto itself.

As for the art from Laura Braga, it stands apart from the other two stories but not in any negative way. In the few pages this middle story gets, she manages to perfectly capture each setting. In each panel, she manages to make each piece feel like a memory in motion. My only critique really is that I wish her faces felt a bit more expressive. As for Ferdian’s colors, he used a very wide range here, making things very pleasing to the eye.

Source: Stjepan Sejic, Image Comics

“The Witch of Leningrad”

In what’s quite possibly my favorite of the three stories, Silvestri and Cady come together to deliver a powerhouse tale. Now, going by the title, it should be obvious to some where this story’s going, so be aware of some sensitive topics in this one. That being said, the action is very tense here and the pacing’s kept tight. Not only that, but the way the witchblade wielder of 1944 kills the Nazis makes for a very exciting and entertaining ride!

When it comes to Boutin’s art, he keeps things very detailed and graphic. This is quite easily the most violent of the three stories, to the point where enemies are being ripped in half. He and colorist Ferdian manage to make this a very bloody and frenetic read, keeping readers eyes glued to the page. Lastly, Peteri really gets the chance to show off his lettering skills here, letting gun sounds and splats litter the page with reckless abandon in the best way.

Final Thoughts

In just three short stories, this team manages to perfectly capture the magic of “A Christmas Carol” in their own horrifying way. Each of these stories is so good in its own way that I’d love to receive spin-offs. Tackling a project like this isn’t easy yet this team made it look so.

Overall Grade: 9/10

Read more from me here and be sure to check out my socials!

Comments

Are you a “Witchblade” fan? Did you manage to pick up the special? Let’s discuss in the comments below!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Eda Thomas Bagwell
Eda Thomas Bagwell
Eda lives with her fiancé, 2 dogs and 3 cats. She’s inspired by the gay icon that is Harley Quinn, and has been reading comics and playing video games since she was 4 years old. You can find Eda writing comic book reviews each week, as well as writing about anime & gaming.

Related articles