Creative Team – Erica Schultz, Luigi Zagaria, Espen Grundetjern, VC’s Ariana Maher, David Nakayama
Published by Marvel Comics
The Story
This comic is reviewed by Nerd Initiative’s Shawn, and your truly, Megan!
Shawn – Erica Schultz isn’t writing this story just for me, but she might as well be. Hitting the mystical side of Marvel in the first panel? You have my attention, ma’am. I always knew, despite his gruff exterior, Remy had a pure soul, but it was so nice to see Schultz make it canon. This issue hit me at an emotional level I didn’t expect.
I grew up with the X-Men. I’ve been reading them for a long time. The growth that Schultz gives us in Rogue with this series is one of the most powerful and emotional stories I’ve gotten from a solo X-Men series. Rogue isn’t running from her past; she’s trying to make a better future. In doing so, Schultz has crafted a series that connects with anyone who believes in simply trying to be better today than they were yesterday. The ending was surprising and satisfying.
Megan – The ending of what’s been a fabulous run was heart-wrenching and emotional in the best way possible. Rogue finally finds out where John is located, and she has a plan to make things right. However, when there’s a bridge burned, is it so easy to rebuild? Rogue finds that out the hard way, and this will be something that sticks with her.

Rogue #5 isn’t the ending you’d expect, but it’s the ending that needed to happen. It was the most realistic ending. Erica Schultz has knocked this miniseries out of the park and ends it on a very interesting note. I’m very excited to see how this story impacts Rogue in the future, and also other factors in the story that are building, namely with Gambit. If you haven’t gotten a chance to check out Rogue, you absolutely should. It’s a fantastic look at who Rogue is as a character, past and present.
The Art
Shawn – Whewwww. Luigi Zagaria and Espen Grundetjern really did a beautiful job with this issue. One of the great things about this limited series has been the interplay between written and visual art. There were issues where the words were subdued and let the art speak. There were other times when the art was built, but the words were the main character. With this issue, it felt like Luigi Zagaria and Espen Grundetjern created a beautiful blend of the previous five issues. Both written and visual art were beautiful.
This was a heavy issue, and the visual side of the team really helped you feel that weight. I felt every tear, every emotion, every bit of pain the characters felt in this issue, not just through the words but through the art. I also felt the joy and love from Remy and Anna Marie. Ariana Maher wrapped it all up in a beautiful bow. She ensured that both the words and the art sang a beautiful song together. Maher made it easy to follow the internal monologue versus the conversation
Megan – Luigi Zagaria, Espen Grundetjern, and Ariana Maher do some really fantastic work in the ending of Rogue. The story itself is emotionally driven, and the artists perfectly captured that. Zagaria’s drawings are expertly done, with the characters showing every bit of emotion in the story on their faces. Grundetjern brings a lot of vibrancy that contrasts the muted tones of an ordinary life very beautifully. Maher carries the emotions of the story through the dialogue excellently, making the reader feel every bit of the story. Together, the artists knocked this out of the park, bringing this wonderful miniseries to a great end.
Final Thoughts
Shawn – 10/10. I’m not a huge fan of limited series, but I would be a bigger fan if more were like this series. This team crafted a full, deep, and satisfying story over the course of five issues. The series shows character growth while reminding us of what the Rolling Stones told us long ago, “you can’t always get what you want, but if you try sometimes you get what you need”.
Megan – 9/10. If you haven’t checked out Rogue yet, there’s no time like the present! If you’re a Rogue fan like me, then this is absolutely the comic run for you!
Overall Grade – 9.5/10
Let us know in the comments what you thought of Rogue #5!





















