Midnight: Fantastic Four #2 – They Were Here and Then They Were Not Here

Published:

Stop me if you’re heard this one before. A brilliant scientist, singularly focused to the point it may cost them everything. While you may have heard the story and maybe have even seen it in Reed Richards in the regular Marvel universe, you’ve never seen it like this. Reed has given up almost everything in his pursuit of The Negative Zone. Now however, Reed has found a kindred spirit in Sue Storm, C.E.O. of Storm Systems.

This review is brought to you by Nerd Initiative’s Eda and Shawn

Creative Team

Writer: Benjamin Percy
Artist: Kev Walker
Color Artist: Frank D’Armata
Letterer: Joe Sabino
Cover Artist: Kev Walker
Cover Color Artist: Guru-eFX

Writing

Eda: Building on from the previous issue, writer Benjamin Percy is slowly but surely building the dread, dreary and long-awaited plot points. While there isn’t much in the way of scares or strangeness here compared to the first issue, Percy works in a lot of atmospheric tension while building the relationships between the characters. While these are different versions of the First Family that we all know and love, he lovingly crafts these new dynamics and backstories in a way that creates intrigue and an interesting four-way dichotomy in a whole new way. However, that may make things all the more tragic and compelling when the inevitable happens and I, for one, can’t wait for that.

As for the pacing here, it feels slow with a purpose. The entire time, I was questioning not just what would happen next, but what character intentions were. As a result of the pacing, I felt like I was being allowed to stew in that, making myself fall deeper into this storyline in a way I haven’t done with Marvel comics in such a long time.

Shawn: I am so into this story. While I’m a longtime horror fan, Midnight:Fantastic Four scratches the itch for me in the best ways. I’ve long been a fan of the eldritch horror in the vein of Lovecraft and Midnight: Fantastic Four #2 leans even further into the feelings of the ancient unknown. Having said that, Percy scratches an additional itch in this issue with the visuals of the script creating a very Hitchcock-esque feel. If there’s one thing that will hook me, it’s a horror story that gives me elements of Lovecraft and Hitchcock. Percy perfectly nails that in Midnight: Fantastic Four #2.

Percy also uses interjectory pages within this comic in a satisfying way. Whether it’s a poem or a message scribbled into a notebook, the story builds an emotional beat with these pages that interrupt the panels. Percy seems to also be building out a manipulative and darker version of Sue Storm (Richards) than we are used to seeing in previous versions of the Fantastic Four. This issue included some twists and turns that I didn’t seen coming that really ratcheted up the story’s tension for me.

Art

Midnight: Fantastic Four #2 Horror Homage Cover by Phil Noto. Image from Marvel Comics

Eda: The work done here by Kev Walker and Frank D’Armata continues to be incredible. While Walker’s new character designs still take a bit of getting used to, his penciling and line work give everything this gothic aesthetic that I absolutely love. With how his creature designs have been thus far, I fear for how things will look if we ever reach the Negative Zone itself. As for D’Armata’s color work, it plays with Walker’s designs beautifully. It comes across on the page that their brains are in-sync as the colors just feel natural and often times spooky or even desolate. Lastly, Sabino’s lettering work is near perfect as it works in tandem with everything from the pacing to the art style all while keeping things easy to follow.

Shawn: My goodness what a beautifully and haunting story from Kev Walker. Walker’s linework leans heavily into the interplay between the light and the shade setting the tone well for this book. I also love that while Percy gives us familiar characters like HERBIE, Walker puts his own unique spin on them. They’re clearly characters we are supposed to connect with but Walker draws you into the story and reminds you these are not the same Reed Richard, Ben Grimm, or Johnny Storm you knew before.

Frank D’Armata shines in this issue. His ability to perfectly parse out what areas of the art would look better shaded vs lit really draws you into the Hitchcock/Lovecraft vibe. D’Armata ensures through colors that when you read Midnight: Fantastic Four #2, you’re seeing it exactly how your mind saw stories in the same vein when you read them while getting into horror. Joe Sabino helps the story shine bringing some mood and emphasis with his lettering. There are some SFX in the issue that really hit home and feel impactful thanks to the way Sabino lays them out.

Final Thoughts

Eda: 9.5/10 -While a bit lighter on the scares, “Midnight Fantastic Four #2” still serves as a great follow-up to the introductory issue. The story Percy is setting up is rich and atmospheric while delivering the team to readers in new and unexpected ways. If the team keeps this up, “Midnight Fantastic Four” may just be a series you need on your shelf.

Shawn: 9/10 – Midnight: Fantastic Four #2 feels like the best parts of those old eldritch style stories. It won’t be blood, guts, or jump scares that keep you coming back. It will be that building tension. The sense of dread and foreboding you feel on your on skin as clear as if you were one of the characters in the story.

Overall Grade: 9.3/10

What did you think? Let us know in the comments below.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

ShawnFoles
ShawnFoles
Originally from Mississippi, Shawn was a fingerprint analyst, and now a Criminal Justice Professor. You can find Shawn on Nerd Initiative writing comic book reviews. However, occasionally he’s forced out of his comfort zone to bring his vast comic book knowledge to our YouTube channel.

Related articles