Share this
Welcome to an all new edition of Parlay Points, the comic book blog to the ODPH podcast via the Nerd Initiative!
For this entry, we’re checking out the latest entry from the fantastic series of comics on Comixology Originals line via Best Jackett Press! CANARY by Scott Snyder, Dan Panosian, Richard Starkings and Will Dennis has been one of the lead books in phase two (along with Barnstormers & Dudley Datson and The Forever Machine) with bringing the horror-western adventure of Marshall Holt’s last ride to readers with much acclaim and excitement. Canary #5 sets up events for the finale next issue but there is much to break down within the latest installment. Let’s take a closer look to see where we are heading for the frightening conclusion, shall we?
*** POSSIBLE SPOILER WARNING ***
A disturbing murder in Utah in 1891 has brought legendary lawman Marshall Holt into its’ investigation before he retires. When the case starts revealing itself, all roads lead Holt back to the town of one of his most chilling investigations: Canary. On that assignment, Holt was introduced to Hyrum Tell, a psychopath who’s heinous activities have scared the bravest of lawmen. The flashback sequences for Tell’s actions speaks LOUD volumes for what kind of evil is inside him.
Upon his return to Canary, Holt crosses paths with Edison Edwards (or Ed-Ed), & Mabel Warren, daughter of Canary founder Chester Warren. The trio set out investigate a cave that has a sinister history that may hold the key to solving the case. With the use of Edward’s Sonotron, the trio investigate the cave’s water levels. When the results are voices saying “WE’RE STILL DOWN HERE!!!”, Holt and company are not prepared for what’s next.
The trio continue to look for clues at an abandoned house for “The Global Geological & Divination Society 1081” or House 1081. The “Canary Evolution” theory becomes a theme as they search the house with discovering a picture of Hyrum Tell connecting to the group. Before they can process what they’ve found, someone has trapped them inside the house and lit it on fire! Meanwhile, Mayor Gem pulls out one of the though dead miners from the cave using Edward’s Sonotron’s. What appeared to be a miracle turns into a nightmare quickly as the minor transforms into a horrific creature!
This issue opens up with a flashback to Holt returning home from the initial Tell encounter and gives some insight on this character but it’s quickly interrupted with the escape from the burning house! Once everyone leaves the house, the smoke from Canary fills the skies and the danger is in the streets. Tommy, the transformed miner is wreaking havoc slashing his sister Nellie and fighting off the town’s people. Holt makes the save but readers witness first hand it might not be enough as he’s attacked by Tommy. When that moment is resolved, Holt wakes to see he’s now in a race against time to stop this evil with more unforeseen factors in play. Can Holt stop what is coming before it’s too late? How does the flashback scenes tie into this? Readers see the beginning of the end as Holt makes his moves setting the pieces in place to bring this story to a heart-stopping finish.
BREAKDOWN: Snyder does a masterful job at bringing this mystery to a boiling point. Once Holt returns from the burning house, his will is challenged by a threat he is nowhere near ready for. The reaction Holt has when Tommy “speaks” to him is terrifying and shows how rattled Holt is knowing what is coming next. Being put on the pedestal of a hero from the first encounter has now been taken away as he is struggling to stop what’s unfolding. Seeing the interaction with the new players is a perfectly placed moment to drive home that Holt is in over his head with very little signs of hope to win. Even when Holt tries giving a rallying speech, it feels flat due to his character being broken down by what has happened. Readers can’ help but see how Holt refuses to quit and get fully invested into his final attempt to thwart this situation. The flashback sequences are mixed in well to give an added layer of fear and uncertainty to connect it with this issue’s conclusion. This is excellent storytelling and dialogue at its best.
The way Holt reacts with his eyes to what is happening is crafted so well by Panosian. Tommy in his new form showcased what danger Holt and the town are facing and held nothing back presenting the terror. Since he wears his bandana during the encounter with Tommy, the only way to “see” his reaction is through his eyes and how he’s shattered by what’s unraveling around him. Even the panel showcasing him talking with Mabel about how they’re going to win doesn’t feel true as his facial expression shows nothing but defeat. Panosian’s attention to this area is incredible. The flashbacks are excellent telling readers on how traumatizing the initial run-in with Tell. It elevated the final moment even more as both parts will be reflecting each other in the closing chapter.
Final Point: Snyder and Panosian bring sheer terror to Marshall Holt and readers with this penultimate issue. The chilling dialogue is paired with equally disturbing imagery to create the sense of doubt in the fabled lawman of this era. The whole series has been a must-read and this issue is no exception. Make sure to check this out on Comixology when it drops (and grab a physical copy when it hits the LCS after its conclusion). This is a book you can’t afford to miss.
Hit me up on ODPH social media and let me know what you thought of Canary #5. Thanks to the team at the Nerd Initiative for allowing the post & thank YOU for reading!
